Seafood Showdown: Italy vs. Portugal's Must-Try Coastal Spots

This is a collaborative post

Both countries border serious stretches of water and have built entire food cultures around what comes out of them. Italy and Portugal approach seafood differently - in preparation, in occasion, in what they consider worth celebrating - and visiting both with that contrast in mind makes the eating more interesting.

Photo credit Luis Castro via Unsplash

Portugal's Southern Coast

The Algarve is where most visitors to Portugal encounter seafood for the first time, and the region delivers reliably if you know where to look. The coastal towns between Lagos and Tavira have the widest range: grilled sea bream, cataplana (a copper-pot stew of clams, chouriço, and white wine), percebes (barnacles eaten by pulling them apart with your fingers), and the ubiquitous grilled sardines that appear everywhere from June onward. The further you get from the main tourist strips, the better the ratio of quality to price. Olhão is the main fishing port in the eastern Algarve and its market - two iron-and-tile pavilions by the waterfront, one for fish and one for fruit and vegetables - sells the catch directly from the boats that landed it that morning.

The train from Lisbon to Faro takes around two and a half hours and deposits you at the gateway to the eastern Algarve, with Olhão, Tavira, and the barrier islands of the Ria Formosa natural park all within easy reach. The park itself - a system of tidal lagoons, salt marshes, and sand islands stretching 60 kilometres along the coast - is where a significant portion of Portugal's clams and oysters are farmed. Boat trips into the lagoon from Faro or Olhão end at islands with seafood restaurants that have no road access and receive their supplies entirely by water. The clams eaten there, pulled from beds a hundred metres away, are among the most straightforward and satisfying things you can eat anywhere on the Iberian Peninsula.

Photo credit Lisha Riabinina via Unsplash

Portugal's Atlantic North

Porto and the northern Minho coast operate on different seafood principles from the Algarve. The Atlantic here is colder and rougher, the fishing culture older, and the cooking less influenced by tourism. Bacalhau - salt cod - is the defining preparation, with estimates suggesting Portugal has over 365 recipes for it, one for each day of the year. Whether that figure is accurate doesn't matter; what matters is that in Porto, bacalhau com broa (salt cod with cornbread) or bacalhau à Gomes de Sá (with potatoes, olives, and hard-boiled egg) appears on menus that have been cooking it the same way for generations. The Mercado do Bolhão in central Porto, recently restored, sells dried and salted fish alongside fresh produce and is a useful introduction to how the city actually eats.

The coast north of Porto around Viana do Castelo and Caminha has a different character again - wide estuaries, green hills dropping to beaches, and fishing villages that receive visitors but haven't been reorganised around them. Lamprey from the Lima river is the seasonal obsession between January and April; it's not for everyone, but the preparation here - braised in its own blood with rice - has a directness that serious eaters find hard to ignore. The Minho region also produces the vinho verde that pairs with local seafood better than anything imported, and the combination of mineral white wine and whatever came off the boats that week is the simplest argument for eating in northern Portugal.

Italy's Cinque terre and Ligurian Coast

The train from Florence to Rome connects two of the cities that most visitors use as bases for coastal day trips. From Florence, the coast at Viareggio and the Cinque Terre are reachable in under two hours; from Rome, the Lazio coast at Anzio and the fishing port of Fiumicino sit within 45 minutes by train. The point is that Italy's seafood geography is accessible by rail from almost anywhere, and planning coastal eating around train connections rather than driving gives you more flexibility and better access to the port towns where the fish actually lands.

Liguria runs along the northwestern Italian coast between France and Tuscany, and its relationship with the sea is embedded in the food in ways that aren't immediately obvious. The region is best known for pesto, but the fishing tradition here is old and specific: anchovies from Monterosso, salt-cured and pressed in terracotta jars, are a different product from anything sold in tins elsewhere. The Cinque Terre villages - Monterosso, Vernazza, Corniglia, Manarola, Riomaggiore - are heavily visited, but the seafood in Monterosso and Vernazza is genuinely good if you eat at the places that have been there for decades rather than those catering to the day-trip crowd. Acciughe al limone (anchovies in lemon) and stuffed mussels are the dishes most specific to this stretch of coast.

Italy's Adriatic Shore

The Adriatic coast offers a different seafood culture from the Tyrrhenian and Ligurian sides - flatter, more industrial in its fishing operations, and less photogenic, but with a directness in the cooking that the more touristy western coast sometimes loses. Ancona in the Marche region is the main port on the central Adriatic and the birthplace of brodetto, a fish stew that varies in its exact composition town by town but always involves multiple species cooked together with vinegar and sometimes saffron. The market at Ancona's port is one of the best fish markets in Italy and worth arriving for at 7am before the professional buyers have cleared the best of the catch.

Further south, Puglia's long heel of coastline produces some of Italy's best raw seafood. Taranto's Mar Piccolo lagoon is where much of Italy's mussel production is concentrated, and eating cozze crude (raw mussels with lemon) at the waterfront in Taranto is the kind of experience that doesn't translate into a restaurant elsewhere. Gallipoli on the Ionian coast and Otranto on the Adriatic both have historic old towns on promontories above the water, and the combination of architecture and seafood eating makes either one a reasonable base for several days. The ricci di mare (sea urchins) available from April to August in this region, eaten simply on bread, are the thing visitors come back for specifically.

The Verdict

Choosing between Italian and Portuguese seafood misses the point - they're answering different questions. Portugal cooks from a tradition of long voyages and preservation: salt cod, cured anchovies, wine-braised shellfish. Italy fragments into regional micro-traditions where the preparation depends entirely on what the local boats land and what the inland larder contributes. Both reward eating close to the water, eating early, and ignoring menus that try too hard to impress.

Conclusion

The best coastal eating in either country tends to happen in places that aren't trying to be destinations - fishing ports, market towns, villages where the restaurant has been in the same family since before tourism arrived. Italy and Portugal both have those places in abundance, and the seafood there is better not because the fish is different but because the kitchen isn't cooking for anyone it needs to impress.